The Fayette Tribune, Oak Hill, W.Va.

Local News

February 6, 2013

Answer filed in civil suit against county deputies, commission

By C.V. Moore Register-Herald Reporter

Police in Fayette County and the Fayette County Commission have filed an answer to a federal civil suit that claims several officers beat a disabled man with excessive force and denied him medical care while responding to a reported shooting in Victor in 2010.

In a document filed in U.S. District Court, the defendants deny the beating, as well as any deprivation of civil or constitutional rights to the alleged victim, Matthew Cole of Ansted.

They also made a motion to dismiss the case, claiming that the original complaint fails to establish that Cole is indeed legally incompetent. His mother, Patricia Cole, filed the original suit with her son and on his behalf under the premise that he is disabled.

The defendants’ lawyer asks for proof that he is legally or medically incompetent and therefore in need of his mother’s involvement.

Lawyers also say the officers are shielded from liability by the doctrine of qualified immunity.

In December, the Coles’ attorney, John H. Bryan, filed federal claims against Nicholas D. Hall, James K. Sizemore and Dana C. Wysong of the Fayette County Sheriff’s Department and Robert V. Neal of the Fayetteville Police Department, though Neal was incorrectly referred to as a sheriff’s deputy.

The Coles claim that Matthew is permanently physically and mentally disabled due to brain injuries from two previous car accidents and is in the care of his mother.

They say that Matthew was with his cousin, the late Jesse Pike, when Pike got into a

domestic quarrel with his significant other. She reported to police that she had been shot in the face with a handgun.

Officers said that when they arrived, they found both Cole and Pike hiding underneath a car with the gun and had to drag them out. Pike was arrested.

The Coles’ complaint says that Matthew was struck in the face, head, legs and chest by the officers despite his not being involved in the domestic incident, resisting arrest or assaulting the police.

Cole was recognized by one of the officers and taken home. His mother says she has photographs depicting the injuries to her son and that he was treated in the emergency room.

The defendants deny any improper conduct, deprivation of civil and constitutional rights or that they caused or observed any of Cole’s injuries, if there were any.

Included in the complaint is a state-based claim against the Fayette County Commission, accusing them of negligence in their capacity as the overseers of the sheriff’s department.

The Coles are asking for damages related to medical expenses, pain, distress and other losses. They also ask for “appropriate training, supervision and discipline” to remedy the alleged constitutional violations.

Neal has retained his own lawyer for the suit.

The next proceeding in the case is scheduled for March 4.

— E-mail: cmoore@register-herald.com

Text Only
Local News
  • 1A1 congrats .jpg Class of 2013 honored at WVU Tech

    West Virginia University Institute of Technology honored the Class of 2013 during the 114th commencement on campus this past Saturday.

    May 15, 2013 4 Photos

  • Commission works on getting facility up and running

    Now that the new downtown amphitheater is up, the City of Oak Hill is taking steps to get it running.
    At a council meeting on Monday night, members considered and eventually passed a rental contract for those who want to make use of the facility.

    May 15, 2013

  • Former Mount Hope man invites city government to engage in sports tourism

    A former Mount Hope resident says the town and the region are ripe to develop a sports tourism industry, given the potential of a unique stadium and gymnasiums at the YMCA building and the former Mount Hope High School.

    May 15, 2013

  • Judge rejects settlement, dismisses negligence claims in alleged school rape

    A federal judge has rejected a $65,000 settlement offer in a case involving the alleged rape of a young girl at the former Mount Hope High School, while at the same time throwing out negligence claims against one of the teachers originally listed in the suit.

    May 15, 2013

  • Nearly 300 graduate at New River CTC

    New River Community and Technical College as well as its nearly 300 graduates proved Samuel Johnson’s assertion that “Great works are performed not by strength, but by perseverance” during the college’s 10th commencement exercises Saturday at the Chuck Mathena Center in Princeton.

    May 15, 2013

  • 7A2 may group.jpg Garden club holds tree planting ceremony

    Woodland Oaks Garden Club met on May Day along the White Oak Rail Trail at the Depot for a tree planting ceremony honoring Brenda Moore, West Virginia State Garden Club President.

    May 15, 2013 2 Photos

  • Farmers Market open

    The Fayette County Farmers Market is open each Saturday in Fayetteville from 7:30 to 11:30 a.m. The market is located in the parking lot of the Convention and Visitor’s Bureau at the entrance to Fayetteville. The market will be held every Saturday at that location through November.

    May 15, 2013

  • SALS to sponsor summer food program

    The Southern Appalachian Labor School announces the sponsorship of the Summer Food Service Program at the SALS Community Center in Beards Fork, Montgomery City Pool and the Historic Oak Hill School. In accordance with federal law and U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) policy, this institution is prohibited from discriminating on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, age or disability.

    May 15, 2013

  • Page-Kincaid recognizes Grant’s 30 years of service

    Mary Grant, the bookkeeper/cashier at the Page-Kincaid PSD for 30 years, retired in early April. Mary started with the PSD in 1983 as the cashier, working with the PSD’s former bookkeeper Dorothy Jeffers. Upon the retirement of Dorothy Jeffers, Mary assumed the duties of bookkeeper and office manager in 2008. Mary also possessed a Class I water operator license and served in a back-up capacity to Bart Jackson.

    May 15, 2013

  • Community invited to meet new leader of state PBS

    The new executive director of West Virginia Public Broadcasting is traveling the state to meet viewers and listeners of the statewide public broadcasting network. Meet Scott Finn on Saturday, May 18  at the Cathedral Café, 134 Court Street, Fayetteville, from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m.

    May 15, 2013